Mega Mistakes: Lawsuits Against the Ohio Lottery Commission
Big Ticket Items:
If you are like roughly 50% of the rest of Americans, then “winning the lottery” is a cornerstone of your retirement strategy. Of the $70 billion or so worth of tickets sold in 2016 (Americans spend more on lotto tickets every year than the individual GDPs of 118 countries), $2.7 billion is spent by Ohioans. That’s a lot of scratch-offs. And yes, you read that right, Americans spend more on the lottery than MOST countries produce.
Who Gets a Share in the Office Pool?
With so much money flying around, it seems like there would be a lot of litigation involving lottery claims. Well- there is. Sort of. Most lawsuits seem to involve office pools with a set of facts similar to the following:
Jim, Bob, and Jane all work at Company X. The three have been in an office lotto pool for years. One day, Jim finds out he bought the winning ticket, but only Jim and Jane chipped in money that day since Bob was out sick. Jim and Jane claim the prize and leave Bob out of it. Bob sues Jim and Jane on the grounds that he should be entitled to a share of the award.
Under Ohio law, these kinds of suits can be brought in your local county court and the judge or jury can decide who the rightful prize-winner/s are based on past conduct, written agreements or records, etc. Yes- this does happen, and people sue each other over it: http://www.10tv.com/article/lottery-lawsuit-winner-offers-advice-workers-office-pools
Suing the Ohio Lottery Commission (OLC)
However, it is exceedingly rare for lottery players to sue the Ohio Lottery Commission, but it does happen. In fact, since 1975, only 88 lawsuits have been brought against the OLC, and many of those suits were unrelated to gaming. These suits must be brought in the Ohio Court of Claims, a special court set up specifically to handle claims against Ohio’s State agencies.
Here is a list of the more interesting cases from the last twenty years or so:
Demetriades v. OLC, 2017-00705
Plaintiff purchased ticket and wins $500, then promptly loses ticket. In an incredible example of selectively optimistic memory, plaintiff remembers that prize was worth $500,000 and sues the OLC. OLC is able to recreate records of ticket and proves that it was only worth $500. Plaintiff still able to purchase 500 items from the Dollar Tree.
Estate of Keefe v. OLC, 2017-10035
Plaintiff wins 5 million dollar jackpot. Clerical error on OLC’s claim form states that the prize was 6 million dollars. Plaintiff paid 5 million, sues OLC for an additional 1 million on theory that claim form signed by OLC employee amounted to a contract. Result? OLC wins, contract forms at time of purchase of ticket and ticket holder is only entitled to the actual prize amount certified by the director of the OLC. Winner died during the case, apparently heartbroken for only having 5 million dollars instead of 6 million.
Maffett v. OLC, 2004-09967; Freiling, et al v. OLC, 2003-11275; Constani et al v. OLC, 2003-11615
These three cases were filed shortly after a widespread ticket misprint made apparent winners in the amounts of $2,500, $50,000, and $2,000,000 respectively.
All three ticket buyers were denied their claims and offered a refund of their ticket price. All three sued and lost for the same reason- misprinted tickets are invalid under Ohio law. Not to worry, the OLC refunded the price of the ticket. No word on whether any of them spent it on another ticket.
Dabaja v. OLC, et al., 2012-08567
Four people all claimed to have purchased a 2 million dollar winning ticket and submitted claim forms. Plaintiff sues the OLC and his co-claimants, who happen to be his ex-wife and two of his family members, to be declared the winner (like Highlander, he believed there could be only one).
Other claimants fail to answer the lawsuit and Plaintiff settles the case and goes home with his lump sum payment (about $700,000). Unclear if Thanksgiving was awkward at the Dabaja household.
Palmer et al., v. OLC, 2002-0778; ORC 3770.07(D)
Creditors had a court-ordered structured settlement agreement with a lotto winner which paid the creditors a percent of lottery annuity payments. The OLC was aware of the structured settlement between the winner and the creditors. Lotto winner defaulted on her payments to creditors and creditors sue OLC for failing to make payments directly to the creditors.
The result was judgment for the OLC- the rights of a prize winner are NOT assignable, garnishable, or attachable, unless by a court order for payment of child support or to an estate. Because- it says so right in the statute. A court can otherwise determine the rightful prize winner/s (for example, multiple claimants in an office pool), but courts are not entitled to assign a winner’s rights to anyone else once the winner is determined. The creditors in this case happened to be lawyers, so of course no real harm was done.
What’s the lesson here? There isn’t one, but as a legal concept “the lottery” is an interesting foray into contract formation. Just remember- if you’re in an office pool, keep a record of your agreement and participants, and don’t tell off your boss before you get your prize money in hand. Also- think about hiring an accountant and a lawyer before you run off and buy that gold-plated jet ski. Good luck!If you are like roughly 50% of the rest of Americans, then “winning the lottery” is a cornerstone of your retirement strategy. Read more here!
Ohio lottery laws
The Ohio Lottery was established to support education programs. The Lottery is a game of chance where participants attempt to win monetary prizes by choosing winning numbers. Ohio Lottery games include the Kicker, daily Pick 3 and Pick 4 games, Rolling Cash 5, Keno, Powerball, Mega Millions and Buckeye 5. There is also an assortment of instant games, where a player can just scratch and win. At any given time, lottery agents throughout Ohio sell approximately 40 “scratch-off” instant games.
Total instant and on-line lottery game sales in fiscal year 2011 were $2.6 billion, ranking the Ohio lottery ninth in the nation. The 2011 fiscal year sales was an all-time record high.
Ohio’s seven horse race tracks are permitted to conduct video lottery sales. Each track may obtain a license to operate up to 2,500 video lottery terminals (VLTs).
For more information on the Ohio Lottery, visit the Ohio Lottery Website.
Dennis Berg, Director
The Ohio Lottery Commission
615 Superior Avenue
Cleveland, Ohio 44113
Players choose five numbers for a chance to win $100,000. This game is offered four times a week on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday.
Daily Pick 3, Pick 4 and Pick 5
Customers can play twice a day at 12:29 PM and 7:29 PM. There are many ways to bet. A player can choose a straight bet, boxed bet, back-up bet, pair bets or wheel bet.
EZPLAY Games are instant play-style games generated through the lottery terminal, with no need to wait for your numbers to be drawn to win.
Tickets are sold seven days a week, and drawings occur every 4 minutes from 6:04 a.m. to 2:28 a.m.
This option can be added to Super Lotto Plus by checking the Kicker box on the Super Lotto bet card or by asking the retailer to provide the Kicker along with the Super Lotto bet. A player wins $100,000 by matching the computer generated six-digit Kicker number in the exact order, $5,000 by matching five digits, $1,000 by matching four digits, $100 by matching three digits and $10 by matching 2 digits.
For each wager, players can select five numbers from a pool of 1 to 75, and one Mega Ball number from a second pool of numbers from 1 to 15. There is the option to play up to five times on each ticket and drawings are held every Tuesday and Friday at 11:00 p.m. EST.
Players select five numbers from a pool of 59, and one number from a second pool of 35 using a bet card. Drawings take place every Wednesday and Saturday at 11:00 p.m. EST and once bet cards are submitted, all sales are final.
Rolling Cash 5
Drawings are held daily at 7:05 p.m. Players must match all five white balls to win the jackpot.
Super Lotto Plus
Players choose six numbers from 1 to 49. Drawings are Wednesday and Saturday nights. The customer chooses to collect either a lump sum or annual payments.
Ohio has six VLT locations.
- Hollywood Gaming at Mahoning Valley in Austintown, opening 9/17/2014
- Hollywood Gaming at Dayton Raceway in Dayton, opened 8/24/2014
- Belterra Park Gaming in Cincinnati, opened 5/1/2014
- Hard Rock Rocksino Northfield Park in Cleveland, opened 12/18/2013
- Miami Valley Gaming in Monroe, opened 12/12/2013
- Thistledown in North Randall, opened 4/9/2013
- Scioto Downs in Columbus, opened 6/1/2012
If you are interested in becoming an agent, contact the Ohio Lottery Regional office and request an application packet. The Lottery Commission requires you to complete the application, consent to a background check and show proof of a $5,000 bond. The license fee is $25.00.
In most cases, you will be required to sell instant tickets for at least six (6) months before you can apply for a license to sell online lottery tickets. Notify your lottery sales representative who will provide you with the application and assist you with its completion.
The Lottery Commission will distribute the online lottery machines to approved applicants based on total instant ticket sales. Therefore, it is important to note that you may be approved to receive an online terminal but because of low instant ticket sales, a machine will not be given to you until first offered to those applicants with higher instant ticket sales.
The amount given to the retail agents is determined by the game. Agents receive a $10,000 bonus for selling a winning Super Lotto Plus ticket, a $1,000 bonus for selling a winning Kicker ticket and a $500 bonus for selling a winning Buckeye 5 ticket.
There are different commitments determined by the legislature for each fiscal year. For fiscal year 2000, the lottery gave $608 million.Ohio lottery laws The Ohio Lottery was established to support education programs. The Lottery is a game of chance where participants attempt to win monetary prizes by choosing winning numbers. ]]>